Give us a call

Homeowners, Auto, and Technology Insurance in Middletown and Newark, DE

PeopleFirst Insurance

We’re a locally owned, independent insurance agency that believes in making clients happy and also that delivers fully customized, cost-efficient policies and plans. Our team of agents is committed to providing insurance that’s first-rate and also to contributing to the communities that it serves.

Our agents are proactive, intuitive, and industrious, and also they’ve served individuals, groups, and businesses in Middletown and in communities throughout Northern Delaware for many years. They work closely with clients in order to create the best possible solutions, and also since the beginning our agents have been passionate about insurance.

Insurance Offerings That Fit You Perfectly

We work with a variety of A-rated carriers, and for this reason among others we offer a vast array of insurance options, which are personal and also commercial.

Our business program keeps almost any commercial enterprise in Northern Delaware secure, and this program has many insurance options, including business owners policies (BOPs), commercial auto, and fleet coverage. We have specially designed programs for businesses in more than 30 different industries, including technology, food service, and real estate. We select coverages from these programs in order to make any commercial policy or plan complete.

For individuals and groups we have homeowners, auto, life, and recreational vehicle policies and plans, and also we have many other personal insurance options. Whether one wants to cover the costs of medical attention or secure a motorhome, we can help him or her.

To learn more about our insurance offerings, please visit or products page.

Engaged, Client-Focused Agents Keeping You Secure

We take a hands-on and detailed approach to serving clients, and this means that we thoroughly assess clients’ needs through one-on-one consultations and risk analyses. Once we know and understand clients’ needs, we identify the right coverages. At the points that the right coverages are identified, we write the best possible policies and plans.

We have quick turnaround times and also we’re reachable whenever clients need to get a hold of us. For this reason, clients get their insurance promptly and also clients can always get information that they need. We review solutions that we create regularly and this ensures that coverages are always current and also that clients’ rates are always competitive.

We’re as committed to being a part of the communities that we serve as we are to delivering the best insurance and the finest services. We support the Appoquinimink and Garnet Valley school districts, and also we support local business owners. We’re members of the Middletown Area Chamber of Commerce and also we participate in local events whenever and however we can.

Contact us or call us today. To start on a policy, request a quote.

Additional Insurance Information:

Also serving: DE, PA, MD, NJ, VA, and NY.

Our Location

PeopleFirst Insurance

PeopleFirst Insurance

5236 Summit Bridge Road
Middletown, DE 19709

Phone Number:

Main office: 302-416-6830
Toll free: 866-285-6475
Fax: 888-229-0267

Office Hours:

Mon: 8:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Tues: 8:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Wed: 8:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Thurs: 8:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Fri: 8:30 AM - 5:00 PM
Sat: Closed
Sun: Closed


Best service around! PeopleFirst insures my business and personal needs with care and personalization every time. Vicki and Lisa have been great.

James, Wilmington, DE
I can't say enough good things about PeopleFirst Insurance. They found an amazing auto insurance rate for us when our last policy renewed at nearly twice its former premium. Linda has been wonderful helping me get a chip repaired in my windshield at no cost. Thanks, PeopleFirst, I love working with a local business that cares about its customers!

Kathleen T., Middletown, DE
I made the switch from AARP to your agency and am getting better coverage and I am saving money.

Dotty, Lewes, DE
PeopleFirst insurance is awesome!!! Saved me over $500 dollars on my car insurance!!!! Made it easy as can be and was really fast! A special thank you to the staff member who took my call, and patiently gave me all the time I needed to gather my information she needed and give it to her over the phone. Not to mention she gave me a call back WITHIN AN HOUR of the good news that I can save a fourth of what I used to pay! Thank you guys so much for the help!!!

Sara K., Northvale, NJ
Your Agency takes care of me. The rates are reasonable and the Customer Service is excellent. Linda is a wonderful person to deal with.

Iphdeller, Middletown, DE