Give us a call

About Our Agency

OUR AGENCY WILL LOOK FOR WAYS TO SAVE YOU MONEY AND QUICKLY HELP YOU ASSESS THE COVERAGE YOU NEED. You will notice the difference from the first moment we answer the phone!

We have access to multiple carriers in multiple states! This means;

  • Unlike many agencies, we can shop your insurance to many carriers at once saving you time and money. This allows us to design your policies to fit your needs and get you the best price instead of being your family being locked into to one carrier’s guidelines or prices.
  • Additionally we will schedule a review with you at least once a year to make sure you have the best coverage at the best price. If something changes we can evaluate staying with your current carrier or re-shop you with other companies. There is no reason for you spend you time calling around and shopping again. We can do that for you right in our agency.
  • If you move, we are licensed and experienced in multiple states. You will have enough to worry about managing your move. Let us take the burden of shopping for new insurance off your busy plate.

What Sets Us Apart

Experience: When you call, email or contact our agency; we will quickly assess the most cost efficient way to give you the coverage you need. We will give suggestions on what policies to combine and what to separate. We will suggest what is best for you even if that means staying where you are or referring you to someone else.

Respect for your time: Here at PeopleFirst, we communicate the way you want to and are flexible enough to adhere to your schedule. “By phone”, “via email”, “online”, or old fashion ”Meet in person”; it’s up to you!

Over the top kindness and service: Wow, this is hard to find these days. We have very high standards on how we treat our clients. Nothing gets under our skin more than substandard service. We treat you they way we would want to be treated.

We have access to many carriers:

Here are just a few of the carriers we represent ensuring you get the best coverage for the best price throughout the states of Delaware, Pennsylvania, Maryland, New Jersey, Virginia and Maine:

  • Travelers Insurance
  • Progressive Insurance
  • Harleysville / Nationwide Insurance
  • Ohio / Liberty Mutual Insurance
  • MSA / Main Street America Insurance
  • The Donegal Insurance Group
  • Chubb Insurance
  • Foremost Insurance
  • The Philadelphia Contributionship
  • Philadelphia Insurance Company
  • Cumberland Mutual
  • Lititz Mutual
  • Coastal Alliance
  • Narragansett Bay Insurance Company
  • And access to many many more!

Choosing Your Insurance Agency

You’re giving valuable business to your chosen agency. So make sure you feel good about them. Are you getting the right insurance protection possible for the money? Will your agency step in and keep the claims process be smooth? Is the agency responsive and available? How knowledgeable and experienced are their agents and staff? … Choose an agency lets you feel safe, listened to, valued, and supported.

Choosing Your Insurance Company

Insurance companies can vary just like any other business: some are well run and financially solid, others may have less stability. You want to buy from a provider with a proven track-record, expertise, and staying power.

Our Mission

PeopleFirst Insurance Inc. will exceed our clients’ insurance needs and expectations by providing the undisputed best service available to them.

We will professionally customize each package to the individual client, enabling them to make the most educated decision to preserve and protect their assets and develop a sound financial plan for their retirement, safety, and family well being.

We are firmly committed to service the best interest of the client and their family in order to form lifelong affiliations with them, their friends, and family.

The Agency and members of the agency team are committed to work together to further a rewarding quality of life while balancing quality family/personal time and career growth. We are committed to maintaining a pleasant environment to service our customers.

Our Location

PeopleFirst Insurance

PeopleFirst Insurance

5236 Summit Bridge Road
Middletown, DE 19709
Main office: 302-416-6830
Toll free: 866-285-6475
Fax: 888-229-0267

Our Providers


Best service around! PeopleFirst insures my business and personal needs with care and personalization every time. Vicki and Lisa have been great.

James, Wilmington, DE
I can't say enough good things about PeopleFirst Insurance. They found an amazing auto insurance rate for us when our last policy renewed at nearly twice its former premium. Linda has been wonderful helping me get a chip repaired in my windshield at no cost. Thanks, PeopleFirst, I love working with a local business that cares about its customers!

Kathleen T., Middletown, DE
I made the switch from AARP to your agency and am getting better coverage and I am saving money.

Dotty, Lewes, DE
PeopleFirst insurance is awesome!!! Saved me over $500 dollars on my car insurance!!!! Made it easy as can be and was really fast! A special thank you to the staff member who took my call, and patiently gave me all the time I needed to gather my information she needed and give it to her over the phone. Not to mention she gave me a call back WITHIN AN HOUR of the good news that I can save a fourth of what I used to pay! Thank you guys so much for the help!!!

Sara K., Northvale, NJ
Your Agency takes care of me. The rates are reasonable and the Customer Service is excellent. Linda is a wonderful person to deal with.

Iphdeller, Middletown, DE